Roger
Ryburn, of Oak Ridge, Tennessee, Glenn Ryburn, a descendant of Diana Powell's Kintyre-born ancestor Mathew
Ryburn, Eric Ryburn, of Alvin, Texas, and
myself have all joined the
Raeburn/Rayburn R165 DNA Project and obtained 37-marker Y-DNA test
results. These Y markers, which follow the male line of descent, are
changed only by sporadic mutations. They allow probability
estimates of a common ancestor
within n generations.
Roger's 12-marker results exactly match Glenn and Eric's, but all are
at a genetic distance of one from me. The 25-marker results have
Roger exactly matching Eric, and me distanced one from Roger and Eric,
and at least three from
Glenn. The
37-marker level has everyone at a distance of four from each
other. In each case, the
37-marker results yeild a probability of only 26-28% of a shared
ancestor within 10 generations, assuming no common ancestors within six
generations.
These results are not as definitive as we would have liked,
but they do
indicate a high probability of a common ancestor going back some
further generations. Mutations can occur at a higher rate than
average, so the connections can be closer than the probabilities
suggest. There are no matches with any Raeburn/Rayburn
participants who are not spelt 'Ryburn'.
The hypothesis for Roger and me has Roger's last Kintyre ancestors as
John Ryburn and Ann Langwill, 9 generations ago. Our earliest possible common ancestors were 10 generations back (but only 7 generations back for
me) -- that is, Mathew and Elizabeth Ryburn,
my probable great x 5 grand parents. More likely connections,
though, are a generation or two My Recent Ancestral Origins Results
before that. It now seems we may
need to go back even
further, but accurate records peter
out this long ago. Glenn's (and Diana Powell's)
earliest
known Kintyre ancestors were Mathew Ryburn and Mary Galbreath, who
married in 1747. The common ancestor between Roger and Glenn
Ryburn is likely to have been at least 9 generations ago, and between
me and Glenn a generation or two before that. We originally
though Eric would join Roger less far back, possibly at the early
Pennsylvania Ryburns, or one generation before that, but that scenario
seems less likely now.
One surprise that has emerged from all our DNA tests is the strength of the
Irish matches in the 'Recent Ancestral Origins' results. There are three times as many
Irish matches as there are Scots. This I had not expected, and it raises the possibility that many of the Ryburns who joined the Duke
of Argyll's Kintyre Plantation Scheme in the 17th century may
have come
from Ireland rather than Scotland. The John Ryburn that fled to
Ireland from Ayrshire after being declared an outlaw in 1603 may
have left an Irish legacy! On the other hand, there may
have been other Ryburns who joined the protestant plantations in
Ireland in even
earlier times. This may explain the Patrick Ryburns that crop up
from time to time, and also the origins of people like Edward Ryburn of
Kilwhipnach farm in Kintyre, who seemed to spring from nowhere.
However, the dominance of the Irish influece appears to require
that the ancestors of the early Ayrshire Ryburns were in fact Irish.
At present we only have four sets of DNA results at the Y37 maker level,
and that is insufficient to build a convincing picture of ancestral
connections. What we need now are some more Ryburn volunteers
that are on a direct male line of descent. In particular, we need
male volunteers from both the US and NZ lines, in order to estimate the
chronology of common ancestry. In New Zealand we need one or two
volunteers from the James Ryburn side, and one more from Robert McNair
Ryburn's side would no go astray either. In the USA we need
male volunteers who directly descend from Diana Powells ancestor,
Mathew Ryburn, but other male Ryburns are also welcome. A few results
from the descendents of Thomas and David Ryburn. Illinois, would be
useful to determine if they are really Ryburns, rather than 'Reyburns',
and if a common ancestor existed. Are there any descendants in
Canada from Kintyre-born Andrew and Margaret Ryburn? And last, but not
least, we have not forgotten there are a few male Ryburns left in
Scotland.
To obtain a DNA test go to 'Family Tree DNA'
and sign up for a Y12, or Y37 DNA test. The Y37 test would
be best, but costs about $260 US. The Y12 test is $150 US. Don't
forget to join the 'Raeburn/Rayborn' project. You will be sent
some swabs that you just rub against the inside of your cheek, and
which you send back in the supplied vials. The samples take some weeks to be processed. Family Tree DNA seems to be
a well-established and respectable company, and you have nothing to worry
about when it comes to privacy. Their science
appears to be first class, and new developments appear at regular
intervals.
Last updated 14 February, 2010
|