Byron Soulsby Normal Byron Soulsby 3 241 2008-02-13T11:44:00Z 2008-02-13T11:44:00Z 3 841 4799 Theodore Lunar Observatory 39 9 5893 9.2720
 

Appendix

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SCHMIDT'S LUNAR ECLIPSE OBSERVATIONS

Byron W. Soulsby

 

Calwell Lunar Observatory Updated by the Isabella Plains Lunar Observatory Australia in February 2008.

 

**** SUMMARY OF CRATER TIMING REDUCTIONS ****

Schmidt's timings were analysed using a series of  QuickBasic V4.5 software programs and are compared in the table below with those of the author which used computed primary contact and selected crater timing predictions for each eclipse, using identical ephemerides.

The reciprocal umbral oblateness (OBL) values were found from a best-fit ellipse program with statistical acceptance limits of  0 < %E < 4  for all primary contact and crater timing results.

                  IMMERSION Crater Timings               EMERSION Crater Timings

 

DATE

OBSERVER

No

MEAN %E

Mean

Error

OBL

No

MEAN %E

Mean

Error

OBL

18420126(1)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

23

1.8987

0.1462

371

27

2.2595

0.1438

42.5

SOULSBY BYRON W.

PREDICTIONS

72

234

2.3530

2.3875

0.0106

0.0035

221

380

1

233

2.0293

2.2252

-

0.0094

-

-

Total No / Mean / me

329

2.3458

0.0150

 

266

2.2295

0.0238

 

18431207

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

4

1.6777

0.4497

-

2

1.1762

0..7065

-

SOULSBY BYRON W.

6

2.0376

0.1368

-

4

2.6109

0.0333

-

Total No / Mean / me

10

1.8937

0.2620

 

6

2.1327

0.2577

 

18440531

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

39

2.0048

0.1413

79.6

41

1.9640

0.1357

50.0

SOULSBY BYRON W.

56

1.2773

0.0305

65.4

0

 

 

-

Total No / Mean / me

95

1.5760

0.0760

 

41

1.9640

0.1357

 

18441124

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

8

2.6295

0.2940

-

0

 

 

 

SOULSBY BYRON W.

58

1.4706

0.0259

66.4

0

 

 

 

Total No / Mean / me

66

1.6111

0.0584

 

 

 

 

 

18470331

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

0

 

 

-

 

 

 

 

SOULSBY BYRON W.

18

1.9148

0.0336

259

1

2.3118

0

-

Total No / Mean / me

18

1.9148

0.0336

 

1

2.3118

0

 

18480319

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

7

2.2270

0.1894

-

23

2.3740

0.1590

-

SOULSBY BYRON W.

55

1.5911

0.0205

79.15

0

 

 

 

Total No / Mean / me

62

1.6629

0.0396

 

23

2.3740

0.1590

 

1849039

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

28

2.5417

0.1386

-

19

1.4980

0.1503

-

SOULSBY BYRON W.

42

2.1423

0.0456

62.3

42

2.2258

0.0218

71.5

Total No / Mean / me

70

2.3021

0.0828

 

61

1.9991

0.0618

 

18510117

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

1

0.8478

-

 

1

1.7952

-

 

SOULSBY BYRON W.

214

2.1039

0.0064

8

2.1068

0.0553

-

Total No / Mean / me

215

2.0980

0.0064

 

9

2.0722

0.0553

 

18520107

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

0

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SOULSBY BYRON W.

58

1.3760

0.0127

371

2

1.6128

0.1593

-

Total No / Mean / me

58

1.3760

0.0127

 

2

1.6128

0.1593

 

18541104

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

0

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SOULSBY BYRON W.

18

2.0781

0.0109

82

3

1.9291

0.0798

-

Total No / Mean / me

18

2.0781

0.0109

 

3

1.9291

0.0798

 

18561013

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

 

1.0470

0.1405

88.8

58

2.6986

0.1193

36.9

SOULSBY BYRON W.

 

1.5014

0.0253

189

1

2.1586

0

-

Total No / Mean / me

 

1.3329

0.0680

 

59

2.6894

0.1193

 

18580227

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

0

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SOULSBY BYRON W.

121

2.3573

0.0134

65.8

9

2.4645

0.0112

207

Total No / Mean / me

121

2.3573

0.0134

 

9

2.4645

0.0112

 

18600207

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

35

1.4711

0.1329

371

60

2.4965

0.1103

41.6

SOULSBY BYRON W.

242
1.8306
0.0107

 

238
2.3817
0.0069

 

Total No / Mean / me

277

1.7851

0.0261

 

301

2.4015

0.0277

 

18600801

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SCHMIDT JULIUS

9